| Lawrence Alexander | Crew | |
| Reporter | ||
| Leslie Becker | Old Lady in a Wheelchair | |
| Passenger | ||
| Brandon Bieber | Crew | |
| Photographer | ||
| Ship's Passenger | ||
| Kelly Bishop | Mrs. Evangeline Harcourt | (Aug 9, 2011 - ?) |
| Stephanie J. Block | Reno Sweeney | (Nov 4, 2011-Nov 22, 2011) |
| Reno Sweeney | (Mar 15, 2012-Jul 8, 2012) | |
| Joyce Chittick | Erma | (Jun 19, 2012-Jul 8, 2012) |
| Robert Creighton during Joel Grey's hiatus | Moonface Martin aka Reverend Dr. Moon aka Public Enemy #13 | |
| Janine DiVita | Passenger | (May 8, 2012 - ?) |
| Ed Dixon | Captain | (May 1, 2012 - ?) |
| Colin Donnell | Billy Crocker | (Feb 21, 2012-Mar 1, 2012) |
| Billy Crocker | (Apr 3, 2012 - ?) | |
| Bill English | Billy Crocker | (Jan 24, 2012-Feb 19, 2012) |
| Billy Crocker | (Mar 2, 2012-Apr 1, 2012) | |
| Billy Crocker | (May 1, 2012 - ?) | |
| Justin Greer while Robert Creighton temporarily replaced Joel Grey | Purser | (Jun 19, 2012-Jul 1, 2012) |
| Julie Halston | Mrs. Evangeline Harcourt | (Jan 17, 2012-Jul 8, 2012) |
| Derek Hanson | Crew | (Jan 2012 - ?) |
| Fred | (Jan 2012 - ?) | |
| Quartet Member | (Jan 2012 - ?) | |
| Ship's Passenger | (Jan 2012 - ?) | |
| John Horton | Elisha J. Whitney | (May 1, 2012 - ?) |
| Tari Kelly during Sutton Foster's hiatus | Reno Sweeney | (Aug 22, 2011-Aug 28, 2011) |
| Gary Lindemann | Crew | (Jul 3, 2012 - ?) |
| Henry T. Dobson a minister | (Jul 3, 2012 - ?) | |
| Passenger | (Jul 3, 2012 - ?) | |
| Quartet Member | (Jul 3, 2012 - ?) | |
| Erin Mackey | Hope Harcourt | (Sep 13, 2011 - ?) |
| Brittany Marcin | Chastity | (circa. Mar 2012 - ?) |
| Kaitlin Mesh | Virtue | (May 22, 2012 - ?) |
| Mary Michael Patterson | Ship's Passenger | |
| Robert Petkoff | Lord Evelyn Oakleigh | (Jan 13, 2012 - ?) |
| Hayley Podschun | Virtue | |
| Brandon Rubendall | Crew | |
| FBI Agent | ||
| Ship's Passenger | ||
| Jeffrey Howard Schecter while Robert Creighton temporarily replaced Joel Grey | Purser | |
| Kiira Schmidt | Passenger | |
| Jessica Stone | Erma | (Jul 31, 2012 - ?) |