| F. Murray Abraham | Roy Cohn | (Jan 11, 1994 - ?) |
| Susan Bruce | Harper Pitt | (Jan 1994 - ?) |
| Kevin Carroll | Belize | |
| Mr. Lies | ||
| Dan Futterman | Louis Ironson | |
| Sarah Ironson | ||
| Megan Gallagher | Harper Pitt | |
| Jay Goede | Joe Pitt | |
| Daniel H. Jenkins | Prior Walter | |
| Cherry Jones | Angel | |
| Emily | ||
| Mormon Mother | ||
| Laurie Kennedy | Ethel Rosenberg | |
| Hannah Pitt | ||
| Henry | ||
| Prelapsarianov | ||
| Rabbi Chemelwitz | ||
| David Margulies | Roy Cohn | |
| Cynthia Nixon | Harper Pitt | (Apr 1994 - ?) |
| Larry Pine | Roy Cohn |