| Jennifer Babiak | Anya A Villager | (Aug 10, 2005-Jan 8, 2006) |
| Barbara Barrie | Yente the Matchmaker | Was replaced in previews |
| Neal Benari | Avram The Bookseller | |
| David Best | Boy | |
| Kristin Carbone | Tzeitel Tevye's daughter | |
| Shandel Motel's mother | (Aug 2, 2005-Aug 21, 2005) | |
| Anya A Villager | (Aug 23, 2005 - ?) | |
| Christopher Cardona | The Fiddler | |
| Dana Lynn Caruso | Fredel A Villager | |
| Sean Curley | Boy | Alternate |
| Craig D'Amico | Vladek A Russian | |
| Hannah DelMonte | Bielke Tevye's daughter | (Jul 19, 2005 - ?) |
| Harvey Fierstein | Tevye the Dairyman | (Jan 4, 2005 - ?) |
| Ben Hartley | Russian Dancer | |
| Vladimir A Russian | ||
| Patrick Heusinger | Fyedka A Russian | |
| Betsy Hogg | Bielke Tevye's daughter | (Aug 3, 2004-Jun 26, 2005) |
| Leah Horowitz | Shandel Motel's mother | (Aug 23, 2005 - ?) |
| Mitchell Jarvis | Yakov the Knifeseller | |
| Jason Lacayo | Nachum the Beggar | |
| Anne Letscher | Anya A Villager | (? - Aug 21, 2005) |
| Andrea Martin | Golde | (Jan 4, 2005-Sep 18, 2005) |
| Janet Metz | Fruma-Sarah | |
| Rivka A Villager | ||
| Rosie O'Donnell | Golde | (Sep 20, 2005 - ?) |
| Alphonse Paolillo | Boy | Alternate |
| Richard Poe | Constable | |
| Elena Shaddow | Grandma Tzeitel | (Mar 8, 2005 - ?) |
| Laura Shoop | Hodel Tevye's daughter | (Jun 11, 2004 - ?) |
| Peter Matthew Smith | Motel the Tailor | (Mar 22, 2005-May 2005) |
| Paul Anthony Stewart | Perchik the Student | |
| Michael Therriault | Motel the Tailor | (May 2005 - ?) |
| Ann Van Cleave | Mirala A Villager | |
| Alison Walla | Shprintze Tevye's daughter | |
| Robert Wersinger | Bottle Dancer | |
| Yussel the Hatmaker | ||
| Lori Wilner | Shandel Motel's mother | (? - Jul 31, 2005) |
| Golde | (Aug 2, 2005-Sep 18, 2005) | |
| Adam Zotovich | Russian Dancer | |
| Sasha A Russian |