During its initial tenure at the Majestic Theatre, this production played five performances when On Your Toes was dark: Sunday, January 10 matinee and evening; Thursday, January 14 matinee; and Sunday, January 17 matinee and evening. When it transferred to the 46th Street Theatre, it played an additional five performances: Sunday, January 31 evening; Tuesday, February 2 evening; Saturday, February 6 matinee and evening; and February 7 evening. The production extended a second time, transferring back to the Majestic Theatre for four final performances: Friday, February 12 matinee; Saturday, February 13 matinee and evening; and Sunday, February 14 evening.