| Kevin Carolan | Ensemble | |
| Governor Roosevelt | ||
| Joshua Colley | Les | Alternate |
| Corey Cott | Jack Kelly | (Sep 5, 2012 - ?) |
| JP Ferreri | A Scab | (Jul 27, 2012 - ?) |
| Ensemble | (Jul 27, 2012 - ?) | |
| Sniper | (Jul 27, 2012 - ?) | |
| LaVon Fisher-Wilson | Medda Larkin | (Sep 11, 2012 - ?) |
| John Michael Fiumara | Ensemble | |
| Specs | ||
| Hogan Fulton | Darcy | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Ensemble | (Nov 1, 2012 - ?) | |
| Romeo | (Nov 1, 2012 - ?) | |
| David Guzman | Ensemble | (Sep 11, 2012 - ?) |
| Mush | (Sep 11, 2012 - ?) | |
| Jacob Guzman | A Scab | (Sep 11, 2012 - ?) |
| Ensemble | (Sep 11, 2012 - ?) | |
| Sniper | (Sep 11, 2012 - ?) | |
| Liana Hunt | Ensemble | |
| Hannah | ||
| Adam Kaplan | Ensemble | |
| Morris Delancey | ||
| Nicholas Lampiasi | Les | Alternate (Sep 11, 2012 - ?) |
| Jake Lucas | Les | Alternate (Sep 10, 2012 - ?) |
| Ron Raines | Joseph Pulitzer | (Oct 9, 2012-Dec 16, 2012) |
| Clay Thomson | A Scab | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Spot Conlon | ||
| Alex Wong | Sniper | |
| Iain Young | A Citizen of New York | (Sep 13, 2012 - ?) |
| Henry | (Sep 13, 2012 - ?) |