| Johmaalya Adelekan | Ensemble | |
| James D. Beeks | Ensemble | |
| Leslie Bell | Ensemble | |
| Dara Paige Bloomfied | The Little Girl | Alternate |
| Amy Bodnar | Ensemble | |
| Donna Bullock | Mother | |
| Scott Carollo | Mother's Younger Brother | |
| Darlesia Cearcy | Sarah | |
| Albert Christmas | Ensemble | |
| Christopher Cordell | The Little Boy | |
| Pierce Cravens | The Little Boy | Alternate |
| Michelle Dawson | Evelyn Nesbit | |
| Joseph Dellger | Father | |
| Erick Devine | Foreman | |
| J. P. Morgan | ||
| John Dossett | Father | |
| Bernard Dotson | Pas de Deux | |
| Roberta Duchak | Ensemble | |
| Mary Sharon Dziedzic | Ensemble | |
| Tina Fabrique | Sarah's Friend | |
| Sean Grant | Ensemble | |
| Jeff Hairston | Ensemble | |
| Anthony Blair Hall | The Little Boy | |
| Paul Harman | Child Buyer | |
| Doctor | ||
| Ensemble | ||
| Davon Harris | Little Coalhouse | Alternate |
| Isaiah S. Henderson | Little Coalhouse | Alternate |
| Rosena M. Hill | Ensemble | |
| Adam Hunter | Ensemble | |
| Michael Hyatt | Sarah's Friend | |
| Kimberly JaJuan | Ensemble | |
| LaChanze | Sarah | |
| Janine LaManna | Evelyn Nesbit | |
| Deidre Lang | Ensemble | |
| Pas de Deux | ||
| Elizabeth Lundberg | The Little Girl | |
| David Masenheimer | Henry Ford | |
| Rusty Mowery | Ensemble | |
| Kimberly Dawn Neumann | Ensemble | |
| Zoie Quinde | Ensemble | |
| Michele Ragusa | Evelyn Nesbit | |
| John Rubinstein | Tateh | |
| Michael Rupert | Tateh | |
| James Stovall | Coalhouse Walker Jr. | |
| Landel Thorman | Little Coalhouse | Alternate |
| Tom Toner | Grandfather | |
| Reporter | ||
| Josh Tower | Ensemble | |
| Ron Trenouth | Child Buyer | |
| Doctor | ||
| Ensemble | ||
| Ann Van Cleave | 2nd Bureaucrat | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Kathleen | ||
| Welfare Official | ||
| Joseph Webster | Ensemble | |
| Alton Fitzgerald White | Coalhouse Walker Jr. | |
| Mindy Franzese Wild | Ensemble | |
| Laurie Williamson | Ensemble | |
| Eric Jordan Young | Ensemble | |
| Pas de Deux | ||
| Bernie Yvon | Harry Houdini |