| Danny Aiello | Phil | (Mar 20, 1985 - ?) |
| Susan Anton | Darlene | (Jan 2, 1985 - ?) |
| Christine Baranski | Bonnie | (Jan 2, 1985 - ?) |
| Alison Bartlett | Donna | (Dec 10, 1984 - ?) |
| Candice Bergen | Darlene | (Oct 23, 1984 - ?) |
| John Christopher Jones Sunday matinees only | Eddie | Alternate (Nov 18, 1984 - ?) |
| Eddie | (Feb 5, 1985 - ?) | |
| Frank Langella | Eddie | (Mar 12, 1985 - ?) |
| Harris Laskawy | Artie | |
| Phil | (Jan 2, 1985 - ?) | |
| Natalia Nogulich | Darlene | |
| John Rubinstein | Eddie | (Jan 2, 1985 - ?) |
| Kevin Spacey | Artie | |
| Lauren Tom | Donna | (Dec 10, 1984 - ?) |
| Christopher Walken | Mickey |