| Benny Baker | Jimmy Smith | |
| Cindi Bulak | Nanette's Friend | |
| Sally Cooke | Flora Latham from 'Frisco | |
| Ruth Donnelly | Pauline Cook at the Smiths' | |
| Larry Ellis | Billy Early a Lawyer | |
| Barbara Heuman Broadway debut | Nanette a Protégée of Sue | |
| Joy Hodges | Sue Smith Jimmy's Wife | |
| Jilly Jaress | Betty Brown from Boston | |
| Judith Knaiz | Winnie Winslow from Washington | |
| Gwendolyn Miller | Winnie Winslow from Washington | |
| Mike Mitchell | Nanette's Friend | |
| Frank Newell | Nanette's Friend | |
| Sandra O'Neill | Flora Latham from 'Frisco | |
| Shelly Rann | Nanette's Friend | |
| Martha Raye | Pauline Cook at the Smiths' | |
| James Robinson | Nanette's Friend | |
| Penny Singleton | Sue Smith Jimmy's Wife | |
| Dana Swenson | Nanette's Friend | |
| Anthony S. Teague | Billy Early a Lawyer |