| Tom Ahearne | Lt. Brannigan | |
| Lance Avant | Dancer | |
| Ralph Beaumont | Dancer | |
| Lynn Bernay | Dancer | |
| Gene Carrons | Dancer | |
| Neil Chirico | Singer | |
| Donn Driver | Dancer | |
| Bob Evans | Dancer | |
| Waiter | ||
| Ralph Farnworth | Singer | |
| Paul Gannon | Dancer | |
| Peter Gennaro | Drunk | |
| Louise Golden | Dancer | |
| Suzanne Hanson | Agatha Mission Band | |
| Susan Hight | Sarah Brown | |
| Jack Konzal | Dancer | |
| Jan Kovak | Dancer | |
| Alicia Krug | Dancer | |
| Al Lanti | Dancer | |
| Ralph Linn | Dancer | |
| Dell Markee | Harry the Horse | |
| Christine Matsios | Mission Band | |
| Maureen McNally | Mission Band | |
| Singer | ||
| Scott Merrill | Dancer | |
| Philip Nasta | Dancer | |
| Al Nesor | Benny Southstreet | |
| Maria Novotna | Agatha Mission Band | |
| Julie Oshins | Nathan Detroit | |
| Joan Petrone | Dancer | |
| Jack Prince | Nicely-Nicely Johnson | |
| Toni Reynolds | Priscilla Mission Band | |
| Singer | ||
| Tom Rieder | Singer | |
| Loretta Rossi | Dancer | |
| Jeanne Schlegel | Mission Band | |
| Singer | ||
| Michael Scrittorale | Dancer | |
| Norwood Smith | Sky Masterson | |
| Ann Sparkman | Dancer | |
| Mimi | ||
| Martha Stewart during Vivian Blaine's vacation | Miss Adelaide | |
| Harriet Talbot | Dancer | |
| Pat Turner | Dancer | |
| Arthur Ulisse | Singer | |
| Kenneth Urmston | Dancer | |
| Ben Vargas | Dancer | |
| Marc West | Dancer | |
| Iva Withers | Miss Adelaide | |
| Gretchen Wyler | Dancer |