| Andrea Anders | The Assistant Desk Clerk | |
| Elaine Robinson | (Nov 19, 2002 - ?) | |
| Jason Biggs | Benjamin Braddock | (Aug 20, 2002-Nov 17, 2002) |
| Mark Blum | Mr. Braddock | |
| Lorraine Bracco | Mrs. Robinson | (Nov 19, 2002-Mar 2, 2003) |
| Christopher Councill | The Hotel Clerk, The Bar Patron, The Psychiatrist | |
| Autumn Dornfeld | The Assistant Desk Clerk | |
| Ben Feldman | The Bellhop, the Man in Bar | |
| Linda Gray During Kathleen Turner's vacation | Mrs. Robinson | (Sep 17, 2002-Sep 22, 2002) |
| John Lavelle Broadway debut | Benjamin Braddock | (Nov 19, 2002 - ?) |
| Kelly Overton | Elaine Robinson | (Sep 3, 2002 - ?) |
| Josh Radnor | Benjamin Braddock | (Jun 11, 2002-Aug 18, 2002) |
| Colin Stinton | Mr. Robinson |