| James Barbour | Officer Lockstock | (Jun 13, 2003-Jul 6, 2003) |
| Anastasia Barzee | Hope Cladwell | (Dec 20, 2002-Mar 16, 2003) |
| David Beach | Mr. McQueen | (? - Jan 18, 2004) |
| Bill Buell While Daniel Marcus was out with a broken ankle | Officer Barrel | (Dec 6, 2001-Feb 17, 2002) |
| Carolee Carmello | Penelope Pennywise | (Apr 29, 2003-Jan 18, 2004) |
| Tom Cavanagh | Bobby Strong | (May 20, 2003-Jul 6, 2003) |
| Dwayne Clark | Robbie The Stockfish / Business Man #1 | (? - Jan 18, 2004) |
| Victoria Clark | Penelope Pennywise | (Jan 28, 2003 - ?) |
| Jennifer Cody Took over for Rachel Coloff when she sprained her ankle | Soupy Sue / Cladwell's Secretary | (Jan 28, 2002 - ?) |
| Little Becky Two Shoes / Mrs. Millennium | (Jul 3, 2003 - ?) | |
| Luther Creek | Bobby Strong | (Jul 29, 2003-Jan 18, 2004) |
| Hunter Foster | Bobby Strong | (Jul 8, 2003-Jul 27, 2003) |
| Danny Gurwin | Mr. McQueen | (Sep 23, 2003-Oct 12, 2003) |
| Spencer Kayden | Little Sally | (Mar 25, 2003-Jan 18, 2004) |
| Megan Lawrence Was with the show off-Broadway; was on maternity leave until Jan 14, 2002 | Little Becky Two Shoes / Mrs. Millennium | (Jan 14, 2002 - ?) |
| Little Sally | (Aug 27, 2002-Mar 23, 2003) | |
| Daniel Marcus | Officer Barrel | (Feb 18, 2002-Jan 18, 2004) |
| Jeff McCarthy | Officer Lockstock | (Jul 8, 2003-Jan 18, 2004) |
| Charlie Pollack | Bobby Strong | (Mar 21, 2003-May 18, 2003) |
| Don Richard | Caldwell B. Cladwell | (Aug 19, 2003-Sep 7, 2003) |
| Charles Shaughnessy | Caldwell B. Cladwell | (Sep 9, 2003-Jan 18, 2004) |
| Amy Spanger | Hope Cladwell | (Jul 8, 2003-Jan 18, 2004) |
| Jennifer Laura Thompson | Hope Cladwell | (Mar 18, 2003-Jul 6, 2003) |
| Kirsten Wyatt | Little Becky Two Shoes / Mrs. Millennium | (? - Jan 18, 2004) |