| Clifford Allen | Ensemble | |
| Guy Allen | Ensemble | |
| Thomas Anderson | Judge | |
| Cynthia Ashby | Ensemble | |
| Pearl Bailey | Mrs. Dolly Gallagher Levi | (Nov 12, 1967 - ?) |
| Beverly Baker | Ensemble | |
| Bryant Baker | Ensemble | |
| Nate Barnett | Rudolph | |
| James Beard | Rudolph | |
| Andrea Bell | Ermengarde | |
| Ed Belson | Ensemble | |
| Fred Benjamin | Ensemble | |
| Maggie Benson | Ensemble | |
| Paul Berné | Ensemble | |
| Marki Bey | Ensemble | |
| Mrs. Rose | ||
| George Blackwell | Ensemble | |
| Judge | ||
| Ted Bloecher | Ensemble | |
| Linda Bonem | Ensemble | |
| Wayne Boyd | Ensemble | |
| Toney Brealond | Ensemble | |
| Gerard Brentte | Ensemble | |
| Sherri Peaches Brewer | Ermengarde | |
| Broadway debut | Minnie Fay | |
| Candy Brown | Horse | |
| Edloe R. Brown | Ensemble | |
| Walter P. Brown | Ensemble | |
| Judge | ||
| Marie Bryant | Mrs. Rose | |
| Cab Calloway | Horace Vandergelder | (Nov 12, 1967 - ?) |
| Chris Calloway | Minnie Fay | (Nov 12, 1967 - ?) |
| Leu Camacho | Ensemble | |
| Horse | ||
| Carlton Carpenter | Cornelius Hackl | |
| Thelma Carpenter Performed Wednesday matinees before taking over the role | Mrs. Dolly Gallagher Levi | Alternate (1969 - ?) |
| Eileen Casey | Ensemble | |
| Joetta Cherry | Ensemble | |
| Donald Coleman | Ensemble | |
| Peter Colly | Ensemble | |
| Dianne Conway | Ensemble | |
| Horse | ||
| Gene Cooper | Ensemble | |
| Patricia Cope | Ermengarde | |
| Jack Craig | Ensemble | |
| Ron Crofoot | Ensemble | |
| Jack Crowder | Cornelius Hackl | |
| Dick Crowley | Court Clerk | |
| Joyce Dahl | Ensemble | |
| Mrs. Rose | ||
| Bowlin Davis | Ensemble | |
| Clifton Davis | Ensemble | |
| Wilbert Davis | Ensemble | |
| Norman DeJoie | Ensemble | |
| Elisa De Marko | Ensemble | |
| Horse | ||
| Richard Deacon | Horace Vandergelder | |
| Stephen deGhelder | Ensemble | |
| Ronald Dennis | Ensemble | |
| Merle Derby | Ensemble | |
| Hamp Dickens | Ensemble | |
| Phyllis Diller | Mrs. Dolly Gallagher Levi | (Dec 26, 1969 - ?) |
| Richard Dodd | Ensemble | |
| Pi Douglass | Ensemble | |
| Catherine Eason | Ensemble | |
| Mark East | Ensemble | |
| Dolores Easty | Ensemble | |
| Edloe Broadway debut | Ermengarde | |
| Eugene Edwards | Ensemble | |
| Alix Elias | Minnie Fay | |
| Ellen Elias | Ensemble | |
| Horse | ||
| Georgia Engel | Minnie Fay | (Dec 26, 1969 - ?) |
| David Evans | Ambrose Kemper | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Harvey Evans | Barnaby Tucker | (Jul 1967 - ?) |
| Anthony Falco | Ensemble | |
| Sergeant Faulkner | Ensemble | |
| Larry Ferrell | Ensemble | |
| Julius Fields | Ensemble | |
| Patte Finley | Irene Molloy | |
| Quitman Fludd III | Ensemble | |
| Don Fontaine | Ensemble | |
| Don Forrest Broadway debut | Rudolph | |
| Morgan Freeman | Rudolph | (Nov 12, 1967 - ?) |
| David Gary | Ambrose Kemper | |
| Ray Gilbert | Ensemble | |
| Ben Gillespie | Ensemble | |
| Olon Godare | Ensemble | |
| Ed Goldsmid | Ensemble | |
| Jack Goode | Horace Vandergelder | |
| Jerry Gotham | Ensemble | |
| Betty Grable | Mrs. Dolly Gallagher Levi | (Jun 12, 1967-Nov 5, 1967) |
| DeMarest Grey | Ensemble | |
| Lavinia Hamilton | Ensemble | |
| Barbara Harper | Ensemble | |
| Horse | ||
| Patti Harris | Ensemble | |
| June Helmers | Irene Molloy | (Apr 1967 - ?) |
| Irene Molloy | (Dec 26, 1969 - ?) | |
| Winston DeWitt Hemsley | Barnaby Tucker | (Nov 12, 1967 - ?) |
| Richard Hermany | Ambrose Kemper | |
| Cornelius Hackl | ||
| Gwen Hillier | Ensemble | |
| Caryl Hinchee | Ensemble | |
| Lolli Hinton | Ensemble | |
| Lawrence Holofcener | Cornelius Hackl | |
| Lee Hooper | Ensemble | |
| Jim Hovis | Ensemble | |
| Katherine Hull | Ensemble | |
| Robert L. Hultman | Ensemble | |
| Scott Hunter | Ensemble | |
| Ernestine Jackson | Ensemble | (Nov 12, 1967 - ?) |
| Irene Molloy | (Dec 6, 1969 - ?) | |
| Reginald Jackson | Ensemble | |
| Sylvia James | Ensemble | |
| Don Jay | Ensemble | |
| Pat Jemmott | Ensemble | |
| Bob Johnson | Ensemble | |
| Waltye Johnson | Ensemble | |
| Jimmy Justice | Rudolph | |
| Keith Kaldenberg | Ensemble | |
| Court Clerk | ||
| Charles Karel | Ambrose Kemper | |
| Voigt Kempson | Ensemble | |
| James Kennon-Wilson | Court Clerk | |
| Ensemble | ||
| Erica Lynne Kerry | Ensemble | |
| Mabel King | Ernestina | (Nov 12, 1967 - ?) |
| Irma Kingsley | Ensemble | |
| David Kirby | Ensemble | |
| Davis Kirby | Ensemble | |
| Gerry Kirby | Ensemble | |
| J. David Kirby | Ensemble | |
| Roger Lawson | Ambrose Kemper | |
| Ambrose Kemper | (Nov 12, 1967 - ?) | |
| Marcia Lewis Broadway debut | Ernestina | |
| Laverne Ligon | Ensemble | |
| Danny Lockin | Barnaby Tucker | |
| Lee Lund | Ensemble | |
| Debra Lyman | Horse | |
| Will Mackenzie | Cornelius Hackl | |
| Ed Mastin | Ensemble | |
| Joe McGrath | Ensemble | |
| Ethel Merman | Mrs. Dolly Gallagher Levi | (Mar 28, 1970-Dec 27, 1970) |
| Dan Merriman | Rudolph | |
| John Mineo | Barnaby Tucker | (Aug 1966 - ?) |
| Bill Mullikin | Cornelius Hackl | |
| Anne Nathan | Ensemble | |
| Charles Neal | Ensemble | |
| Gail Nelson | Ensemble | |
| Sean Nolan | Ensemble | |
| Peter Oliver Norman | Ensemble | |
| Russell Nype | Cornelius Hackl | (Mar 28, 1970 - ?) |
| Alexander Orfaly | Ensemble | |
| Kay Oslin | Ensemble | |
| Bibi Osterwald | Mrs. Dolly Gallagher Levi | (Nov 6, 1967-Nov 11, 1967) |
| Janice Painchaud | Ensemble | |
| Joni Palmer | Ensemble | |
| Leland Palmer | Minnie Fay | (Jul 1967 - ?) |
| Patti Pappathatos | Ensemble | |
| Horse | ||
| Jacqueline Payne | Ensemble | |
| Michael Podwal | Ensemble | |
| Yolanda Poropat | Mrs. Rose | |
| Howard Porter | Ambrose Kemper | |
| Zelda Pulliam | Ensemble | |
| Jane Quinn | Ensemble | |
| Marion Ramsey | Ermengarde | |
| Martha Raye | Mrs. Dolly Gallagher Levi | (Feb 27, 1967 - ?) |
| Jozella Reed | Ensemble | |
| Bob Remick | Ensemble | |
| Ellie Rogers | Ensemble | |
| Ginger Rogers | Mrs. Dolly Gallagher Levi | (Aug 9, 1966 - ?) |
| Patricia Sauers | Ernestina | |
| Kenneth Scott | Ensemble | |
| Saundra Sharp | Ensemble | |
| Vanessa Shaw | Ensemble | |
| Max Showalter | Horace Vandergelder | (Mar 13, 1967 - ?) |
| Bettiane Shumska | Ensemble | |
| E. B. Smith | Ensemble | |
| Pat Stevens | Ensemble | |
| Luke Stover | Ensemble | |
| Melvin Taylor | Ensemble | |
| Freda Turner | Ensemble | |
| Wyetta Turner | Ensemble | |
| Delores Vanison | Ensemble | |
| Freda Vanterpool | Ensemble | |
| Elise Warner | Ensemble | |
| Alyce Webb | Ernestina | |
| Sarah White | Ensemble | |
| Joe Williams | Ensemble | |
| Lee Wilson | Ensemble | (Aug 21, 1967 - ?) |
| Celestine Winters | Horse | |
| Emily Yancy | Irene Molloy | (Nov 12, 1967 - ?) |
| John Young | Ensemble | |
| Ronald Young | Ambrose Kemper |