Shows
People
Theatres
Awards
search
menu
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Musical
Comedy
Original
Broadway
Opening Date
Nov 20, 2025
Closing Date
1st Preview
Nov 01, 2025
1st Preview
Nov 01, 2025
Previews
21
Performances
(as of Jun 28, 2026)
252
Musical
Comedy
Original
Broadway
External Links
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) Tickets
Official Website
Open Date: Nov 20, 2025
Close Date:
Closed Flag: n
Is Final Week:
ABOUT THIS PRODUCTION
Theatres
Longacre Theatre
(Nov 20, 2025 - Present)
Media
See all
5
photos
People
Production Staff
Opening Night Cast
Replacements
Theatre Owned / Operated by
The Shubert Organization (Robert E. Wankel: Chairman and CEO; Jeff T. Daniel: President; Elliot Greene: Chief Operating Officer)
Lead Producer:
Kevin McCollum
,
Tim Johanson
,
Glass Half Full Productions
and
Jamie Wilson Productions
; Co-Produced by
Evan McGill
,
Dennis Trunfio
,
Abrams Corr Riemer Productions
,
Marc David Levine & Stephen S. Miller
,
Laura Lonergan
,
James L. Nederlander
,
Michael Patrick & Paul Gavriani
,
Merrie L. Davis / Tony Spinosa & Barbara Gallay
,
Walport Productions
,
Agrawal & PBT / JKDNV Productions
,
Aleff & Nothing Ventured / Flatto Turchin
,
Pam & Stephen Della Pietra
,
Nicole Eisenberg / Willette & Manny Klausner
,
Liddell Shilaimon / John Voege
,
Cecilia Lin / Wanyue Jie
,
Kevin Shen / We Believe
,
The Transatlantic Alliance / IPN
,
Oki Wallace-Phoebe / Laurie Tisch & Greg Field
,
Clemmie Forfar
,
Oliver Mackwood
,
Victoria Weinberg
and
Lucas McMahon
; Presenting the production by
The Kiln Theatre
; Associate Producer:
Jack Eidson
,
Jonny Godbold
,
Amy Hetherington
,
Harrison Rose
and
Evan Shalat
Book by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
; Music by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
; Lyrics by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
; Music orchestrated by
Lux Pyramid
; Musical Director:
Ted Arthur
Directed by
Tim Jackson
; Choreographed by
Tim Jackson
; Associate Director:
Asmeret Ghebremichael
; Associate Choreographer:
Asmeret Ghebremichael
Scenic Design by
Soutra Gilmour
; Costume Design by
Soutra Gilmour
; Lighting Design by
Jack Knowles
; Sound Design by
Tony Gayle
; Hair and Wig Design by
Cheryl Thomas
; Make-Up Design by
Cheryl Thomas
; Associate Scenic Design:
Brian Webb
; Associate Costume Design:
Ricky Lurie
; Associate Lighting Design:
Jessica Creager
and
Kirk Fitzgerald
; Associate Sound Design:
Cody Spencer
; Assistant Scenic Design:
Lily Tomasic
; Assistant Costume Design:
Jess Gersz
; Assistant Lighting Design:
Hope Debelius
; Moving Light Programmers:
Sumner Ellsworth
and
Jonah Camiel
General Manager:
Theater Matters
,
John E. Gendron
and
Ashley Berman
; Company Manager:
Eric Rothstein
; Assistant Co. Mgr:
Michelle Yard
Production Manager:
Hudson Theatrical Associates
; Production Stage Manager:
Judith Schoenfeld
; Stage Manager:
Alfredo Macias
; Assistant Stage Mgr:
Thea McRae
Musical Supervisor:
Nick Finlow
; Music Production:
Lux Pyramid
; Musical Coordinator:
John Miller
; Conducted by
Ted Arthur
; Associate Conductor:
Kevin Ramessar
; Keyboard:
Ted Arthur
; Guitar:
Kevin Ramessar
; Bass:
Lee Nadel
; Drums:
Rocky Bryant
; Percussion:
Jessie Linden
; Keyboard Programmer:
Randy Cohen
and
Randy Cohen Keyboards
; Music Preparation:
Utsav Bhargava
and
Chris Guard
Original UK Casting:
Julia Horan CDG
; US Casting:
C12 Casting
and
Stephen Kopel, CSA
; Advertising & Marketing:
The Pekoe Group
; Press Representative:
Vivacity Media Group
; Dance Captain:
Phoenix Best
; Photographer:
Matthew Murphy
and
Evan Zimmerman
Christiani Pitts
Robin
Sam Tutty
Broadway debut
Dougal
Standby:
Phoenix Best
(Robin) and
Vincent Michael
(Dougal)
Longacre Theatre
(Nov 20, 2025 - Present)
Associate Producer:
Leila Sykes
Standby:
Austin Colburn
(Dougal) and
Jana Larell Glover
(Robin)
Songs
music by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
; lyrics by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
Act 1
Sung By
New York
Dougal
Dad
Dougal
What'll It Be
Robin
On the App
Robin and Dougal
This Is the Place
Robin and Dougal
Under the Mistletoe
Robin and Dougal
Be Happy
Robin
American Express
Robin and Dougal
Act 2
Sung By
The Hangover Duet
Robin and Dougal
He Doesn't Exist
Robin
What Did You Say?
Robin and Dougal
New York / What'll It Be
Robin and Dougal
About to Go In
Dougal
This Year
Robin
Dearly Beloved
Robin and Dougal
If I Believed
Robin and Dougal
New York / What'll It Be
(Reprise)
Robin and Dougal
Awards
Tony Award®
Best Musical
2026 Nominee
Best Book of a Musical
2026 Nominee
Book by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
Best Original Score Written for the Theatre
2026 Nominee
Music by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
Lyrics by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical
2026 Nominee
Sam Tutty
Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Musical
2026 Nominee
Christiani Pitts
Best Direction of a Musical
2026 Nominee
Directed by
Tim Jackson
Best Orchestrations
2026 Nominee
Music orchestrated by
Lux Pyramid
Best Scenic Design of a Musical
2026 Nominee
Scenic Design by
Soutra Gilmour
Drama Desk Award
Outstanding Musical
2026 Nominee
Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical
2026 Nominee
Sam Tutty
Outstanding Lyrics
2026 Winner
Lyrics by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
Theatre World
Award
2026 Recipient
Sam Tutty
Statistics
Season:
2026-27
2025-26
View Graph
Week Ending
Gross
% Gross Pot.
Attendance
% Capacity
# Previews
# Perf.
Statistics supplied are courtesy of
The Broadway League
.
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) Statistics
2026-27 Season
2025-26 Season
GROSS
ATTENDANCE
Gross
Week Ending
Attendance
Week Ending
People
Songs
Awards
Statistics
Production Staff
Opening Night Cast
Replacements
Theatre Owned / Operated by
The Shubert Organization (Robert E. Wankel: Chairman and CEO; Jeff T. Daniel: President; Elliot Greene: Chief Operating Officer)
Lead Producer:
Kevin McCollum
,
Tim Johanson
,
Glass Half Full Productions
and
Jamie Wilson Productions
; Co-Produced by
Evan McGill
,
Dennis Trunfio
,
Abrams Corr Riemer Productions
,
Marc David Levine & Stephen S. Miller
,
Laura Lonergan
,
James L. Nederlander
,
Michael Patrick & Paul Gavriani
,
Merrie L. Davis / Tony Spinosa & Barbara Gallay
,
Walport Productions
,
Agrawal & PBT / JKDNV Productions
,
Aleff & Nothing Ventured / Flatto Turchin
,
Pam & Stephen Della Pietra
,
Nicole Eisenberg / Willette & Manny Klausner
,
Liddell Shilaimon / John Voege
,
Cecilia Lin / Wanyue Jie
,
Kevin Shen / We Believe
,
The Transatlantic Alliance / IPN
,
Oki Wallace-Phoebe / Laurie Tisch & Greg Field
,
Clemmie Forfar
,
Oliver Mackwood
,
Victoria Weinberg
and
Lucas McMahon
; Presenting the production by
The Kiln Theatre
; Associate Producer:
Jack Eidson
,
Jonny Godbold
,
Amy Hetherington
,
Harrison Rose
and
Evan Shalat
Book by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
; Music by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
; Lyrics by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
; Music orchestrated by
Lux Pyramid
; Musical Director:
Ted Arthur
Directed by
Tim Jackson
; Choreographed by
Tim Jackson
; Associate Director:
Asmeret Ghebremichael
; Associate Choreographer:
Asmeret Ghebremichael
Scenic Design by
Soutra Gilmour
; Costume Design by
Soutra Gilmour
; Lighting Design by
Jack Knowles
; Sound Design by
Tony Gayle
; Hair and Wig Design by
Cheryl Thomas
; Make-Up Design by
Cheryl Thomas
; Associate Scenic Design:
Brian Webb
; Associate Costume Design:
Ricky Lurie
; Associate Lighting Design:
Jessica Creager
and
Kirk Fitzgerald
; Associate Sound Design:
Cody Spencer
; Assistant Scenic Design:
Lily Tomasic
; Assistant Costume Design:
Jess Gersz
; Assistant Lighting Design:
Hope Debelius
; Moving Light Programmers:
Sumner Ellsworth
and
Jonah Camiel
General Manager:
Theater Matters
,
John E. Gendron
and
Ashley Berman
; Company Manager:
Eric Rothstein
; Assistant Co. Mgr:
Michelle Yard
Production Manager:
Hudson Theatrical Associates
; Production Stage Manager:
Judith Schoenfeld
; Stage Manager:
Alfredo Macias
; Assistant Stage Mgr:
Thea McRae
Musical Supervisor:
Nick Finlow
; Music Production:
Lux Pyramid
; Musical Coordinator:
John Miller
; Conducted by
Ted Arthur
; Associate Conductor:
Kevin Ramessar
; Keyboard:
Ted Arthur
; Guitar:
Kevin Ramessar
; Bass:
Lee Nadel
; Drums:
Rocky Bryant
; Percussion:
Jessie Linden
; Keyboard Programmer:
Randy Cohen
and
Randy Cohen Keyboards
; Music Preparation:
Utsav Bhargava
and
Chris Guard
Original UK Casting:
Julia Horan CDG
; US Casting:
C12 Casting
and
Stephen Kopel, CSA
; Advertising & Marketing:
The Pekoe Group
; Press Representative:
Vivacity Media Group
; Dance Captain:
Phoenix Best
; Photographer:
Matthew Murphy
and
Evan Zimmerman
Christiani Pitts
Robin
Sam Tutty
Broadway debut
Dougal
Standby:
Phoenix Best
(Robin) and
Vincent Michael
(Dougal)
Longacre Theatre
(Nov 20, 2025 - Present)
Associate Producer:
Leila Sykes
Standby:
Austin Colburn
(Dougal) and
Jana Larell Glover
(Robin)
music by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
; lyrics by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
Act 1
Sung By
New York
Dougal
Dad
Dougal
What'll It Be
Robin
On the App
Robin and Dougal
This Is the Place
Robin and Dougal
Under the Mistletoe
Robin and Dougal
Be Happy
Robin
American Express
Robin and Dougal
Act 2
Sung By
The Hangover Duet
Robin and Dougal
He Doesn't Exist
Robin
What Did You Say?
Robin and Dougal
New York / What'll It Be
Robin and Dougal
About to Go In
Dougal
This Year
Robin
Dearly Beloved
Robin and Dougal
If I Believed
Robin and Dougal
New York / What'll It Be
(Reprise)
Robin and Dougal
Tony Award®
Best Musical
2026 Nominee
Best Book of a Musical
2026 Nominee
Book by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
Best Original Score Written for the Theatre
2026 Nominee
Music by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
Lyrics by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical
2026 Nominee
Sam Tutty
Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Musical
2026 Nominee
Christiani Pitts
Best Direction of a Musical
2026 Nominee
Directed by
Tim Jackson
Best Orchestrations
2026 Nominee
Music orchestrated by
Lux Pyramid
Best Scenic Design of a Musical
2026 Nominee
Scenic Design by
Soutra Gilmour
Drama Desk Award
Outstanding Musical
2026 Nominee
Outstanding Lead Performance in a Musical
2026 Nominee
Sam Tutty
Outstanding Lyrics
2026 Winner
Lyrics by
Jim Barne
and
Kit Buchan
Theatre World
Award
2026 Recipient
Sam Tutty
Season:
2026-27
2025-26
View Graph
Week Ending
Gross
% Gross Pot.
Attendance
% Capacity
# Previews
# Perf.
Statistics supplied are courtesy of
The Broadway League
.
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) Statistics
2026-27 Season
2025-26 Season
GROSS
ATTENDANCE
Gross
Week Ending
Attendance
Week Ending
PRODUCTIONS
More Productions by Opening Date
Call Me Izzy
Jun 12, 2025
Aug 24, 2025
Mamma Mia!
Aug 14, 2025
Feb 01, 2026
Jeff Ross: Take A Banana For The Ride
Aug 18, 2025
Sep 28, 2025
Art
Sep 16, 2025
Dec 21, 2025
Waiting for Godot
Sep 28, 2025
Jan 04, 2026
Punch
Sep 29, 2025
Nov 02, 2025
Beetlejuice
Oct 08, 2025
Jan 03, 2026
Ragtime
Oct 16, 2025
Aug 16, 2026
Liberation
Oct 28, 2025
Feb 01, 2026
Little Bear Ridge Road
Oct 30, 2025
Dec 21, 2025
The Queen of Versailles
Nov 09, 2025
Dec 21, 2025
Oedipus
Nov 13, 2025
Feb 08, 2026
Rob Lake Magic with Special Guests The Muppets
Nov 14, 2025
Nov 16, 2025
Chess
Nov 16, 2025
Jun 21, 2026
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Nov 20, 2025
Present
Marjorie Prime
Dec 08, 2025
Feb 15, 2026
All Out: Comedy About Ambition
Dec 12, 2025
Mar 08, 2026
Bug
Jan 08, 2026
Mar 08, 2026
Every Brilliant Thing
Mar 12, 2026
Aug 09, 2026
Giant
Mar 23, 2026
Jun 28, 2026
Dog Day Afternoon
Mar 30, 2026
Jul 12, 2026
Becky Shaw
Apr 06, 2026
Jun 14, 2026
CATS: The Jellicle Ball
Apr 07, 2026
Present
Death of a Salesman
Apr 09, 2026
Aug 09, 2026
Titaníque
Apr 12, 2026
Sep 20, 2026
The Fear of 13
Apr 15, 2026
Jun 28, 2026
Proof
Apr 16, 2026
Jul 19, 2026
Fallen Angels
Apr 19, 2026
Jun 07, 2026
Schmigadoon!
Apr 20, 2026
Jan 03, 2027
The Balusters
Apr 21, 2026
Jun 21, 2026
Beaches, A New Musical
Apr 22, 2026
May 24, 2026
The Rocky Horror Show
Apr 23, 2026
Nov 29, 2026
Joe Turner's Come and Gone
Apr 25, 2026
Jul 26, 2026
The Lost Boys
Apr 26, 2026
Present
Celebrity Autobiography
May 18, 2026
Jun 21, 2026
1/5):
Close
Search
search
in
Category
All
Shows
People
Organizations
Theatres
Seasons
Looking for more categories?
Search
Close
Home
Shows
People
Organizations
Theatres
Seasons
Characters
Awards
Songs
Statistics
Advanced Search
FAQ
Help
About
Policies
Contact