| ACT 1 | Sung By |
|---|
| Wonder Why? | 'Joth' Jotham |
| Nuthin' Like a Celebration | The Neighbors |
| There's a Certain Kind o'Jingle to My Spurs | Moose (One of the Four Cowhands), Slugger (One of the Four Cowhands), Smokey (One of the Four Cowhands) and Sundown (One of the Four Cowhands) |
| I'm the Luckiest Girl Alive | Jennifer and Neighbors |
| When I Point My Finger at My Neighbor | Spindle and Cowhands |
| Nothing's Ever Quite Like This | Jennifer and Widow Waggle |
| Twickenham School for Girls | School Girls |
| Have You Heard? | Mrs. Whipple and Gossip Chorus |
| There's a Certain Kind o'Jingle to My Spurs (Reprise) | Moose (One of the Four Cowhands), Slugger (One of the Four Cowhands), Smokey (One of the Four Cowhands) and Sundown (One of the Four Cowhands) |
| Wonder Why? (Reprise) | 'Joth' Jotham |
| ACT 2 | Sung By |
|---|
| When I Grow Up | The Waggle Kids |
| The Omelet Song | Widow Waggle, The Waggle Kids and Cowhands |
| Somewhere in the Heart of a Man | 'Joth' Jotham, Spindle and Jennifer |
| Change in a Home on the Range | 'Joth' Jotham and Jennifer |
| Look to the Mountains | 'Joth' Jotham, Jennifer and Neighbors |
| Finale | The Whole Valley (Entire Company) |
