| ACT 1 |
|---|
| Song List | | Sung By |
|---|
| A Very Special Day | | Jeanie (Chorus Singer) and Trio |
| That's The Way It Happens | | Jeanie (Chorus Singer) and Trio |
| That's The Way It Happens (Reprise) | | Larry (Assistant Stage Manager) |
| Dance Impromptu | | Chorus, George (2nd Assistant Stage Manager) and Trio |
| Overture to "Me and Juliet" | | Dario (Conductor) and Orchestra |
| Opening of "Me and Juliet" | | Lily (Juliet) (Singing Principal), Jim (Don Juan) (Principal Dancer), Susie (Carmen) (Principal Dancer) and Charlie (Me) (Featured Lead) |
| Marriage Type Love | | Charlie (Me) (Featured Lead), Lily (Juliet) (Singing Principal) and Singers |
| Keep It Gay | | Bob (Electrician), Jim (Don Juan) (Principal Dancer) and Chorus |
| Keep It Gay (Reprise) | | Betty (successor to Susie as Principal Dancer) and Buzz (Principal Dancer) |
| The Big, Black Giant | | Larry (Assistant Stage Manager) |
| No Other Love | | Jeanie (Chorus Singer) and Larry (Assistant Stage Manager) |
| The Big, Black Giant (Reprise) | | Ruby (Company Manager) |
| It's Me | | Betty (successor to Susie as Principal Dancer) and Jeanie (Chorus Singer) |
| First Act Finale of "Me and Juliet" | | Lily (Juliet) (Singing Principal), Betty (successor to Susie as Principal Dancer), Charlie (Me) (Featured Lead), Jim (Don Juan) (Principal Dancer), Jeanie (Chorus Singer) and Chorus |
| ACT 2 |
|---|
| Song List | | Sung By |
|---|
| Intermission Talk | | Herbie (Candy Counter Boy) and Chorus |
| It Feels Good | | Bob (Electrician) |
| Sequence in Second Act of "Me and Juliet" | | Charlie (Me) (Featured Lead), Jim (Don Juan) (Principal Dancer), Lily (Juliet) (Singing Principal) and Dancers |
| The Baby You Love | | Lily (Juliet) (Singing Principal) and Dancers |
| We Deserve Each Other | | Betty (successor to Susie as Principal Dancer), Jim (Don Juan) (Principal Dancer) and Chorus |
| I'm Your Girl | | Jeanie (Chorus Singer) and Larry (Assistant Stage Manager) |
| Second Act Finale of "Me and Juliet" | | Charlie (Me) (Featured Lead), Lily (Juliet) (Singing Principal), Betty (successor to Susie as Principal Dancer), Jim (Don Juan) (Principal Dancer) and Chorus |
| Finale of Our Play | | Entire Company |
