| ACT 1 |
| Song List | | Sung By |
| Strange New World | | Mr. Parkhill |
| OOOO-EEEE | | Hyman Kaplan, Rose Mitnick, Mr. Parkhill and Students |
| A Dedicated Teacher | | Eileen Higby, Marie Vitale and Mr. Parkhill |
| Lieben Dich | | Hyman Kaplan |
| Loving You | | Rose Mitnick |
| The Day I Met Your Father | | Mrs. Mitnick |
| Anything Is Possible | | Hyman Kaplan, Students, Dancers and Singers |
| Spring in the City | | Kathy McKenna, Giovanni Pastora, Reben Plonsky, Sam Pinsky, Mrs. Moskowitz, Fanny Gidwitz, Dancers and Singers |
| ACT 2 |
| Song List | | Sung By |
| Old Fashioned Husband | | Yissel Fishbein |
| Julius Caesar | | Hyman Kaplan |
| I Never Felt Better in My Life | | Hyman Kaplan, Dancers and Singers |
| When Will I Learn | | Rose Mitnick |
| All American | | Sam Pinsky and Students |