| 2002 Tony Award® Best Play |
|---|
| | Metamorphoses [nominee] Produced in association with Second Stage Theatre (Carole Rothman: artistic director; Carol Fishman: managing director) |
| 2002 Drama Desk Award Outstanding New Play |
|---|
 | Metamorphoses [winner] Produced in association with Second Stage Theatre (Carole Rothman: artistic director; Carol Fishman: managing director) |
| 2001 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Revival of a Play |
|---|
| | Second Stage Theatre (Carole Rothman: artistic director; Carol Fishman: managing director) (for "Tiny Alice") [nominee] |
| 2000 Drama Desk Award Outstanding New Musical |
|---|
| | Second Stage Theatre (Carole Rothman: artistic director; Carol Fishman: managing director) (for "Saturday Night") [nominee] |
| 2000 Drama Desk Award Outstanding New Play |
|---|
| | Second Stage Theatre (Carole Rothman: artistic director; Carol Fishman: managing director) (for "Jitney") [nominee] |
| 1994 Drama Desk Award Unique Theater Experience |
|---|
| | Second Stage Theatre (Carole Rothman: artistic director; Carol Fishman: managing director) (for "Ricky Jay and His 52 Assistants") [nominee] |