| 1995 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Musical |
|---|
| | The York Theatre Company (Janet Hayes Walker, Producing Director) (for "Merrily We Roll Along") [nominee] |
| 1994 Drama Desk Award Special Achievement Award |
|---|
 | Janet Hayes Walker (for 25 years at the York Theatre Company) [winner] |
| 1989 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Revival |
|---|
| | Sweeney Todd [nominee]
Produced Off-Off Broadway by The York Theatre Company (Janet Hayes Walker, Producing Director) |
| 1988 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Revival |
|---|
| | The York Theatre Company (Janet Hayes Walker, Producing Director) (for "Lost in the Stars") [nominee] |
