| 2013 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Costume Design |
|---|
| | Paloma Young (for "Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812") [nominee] |
| 2012 Tony Award® Best Costume Design of a Play |
|---|
 | Peter and the Starcatcher [winner] Costume Design by Paloma Young |
| 2011 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Costume Design |
|---|
| | Paloma Young (for "Peter and the Starcatcher") [nominee] |