| 2011 Tony Award® Best Musical |
|---|
| | The Scottsboro Boys [nominee] Produced by Vineyard Theatre |
| 2010 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Musical |
|---|
| | Vineyard Theatre (Douglas Aibel: Artistic Director; Jennifer Garvey-Blackwell: Executive Director) (for "The Scottsboro Boys") [nominee] |
| 2008 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Musical |
|---|
| | Vineyard Theatre (Douglas Aibel: Artistic Director; Jennifer Garvey-Blackwell: Executive Director) (for "The Slug Bearers of Kayrol Island") [nominee] |
| 2004 Tony Award® Best Musical |
|---|
 | Avenue Q [winner] Produced by Vineyard Theatre (Douglas Aibel: Artistic Director; Bardo Ramirez: Managing Director) |
| 2003 Drama Desk Award Outstanding New Musical |
|---|
| | Avenue Q [nominee] Produced by Vineyard Theatre (Douglas Aibel: Artistic Director; Bardo Ramirez: Managing Director) |
| 1998 Drama Desk Award Special Award |
|---|
 | Vineyard Theatre (Douglas Aibel: Artistic Director; Bardo Ramirez: Managing Director) (for quality work & the new S.P.A.C.E. program) [winner] |
| 1997 Drama Desk Award Outstanding New Play |
|---|
 | Vineyard Theatre (Douglas Aibel: Artistic Director; Jon Nakagawa: Managing Director) (for "How I Learned to Drive") [winner] |
| 1996 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Musical |
|---|
| | Vineyard Theatre (Douglas Aibel: Artistic Director; Jon Nakagawa: Managing Director) (for "Bed and Sofa") [nominee] |
| 1995 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Play |
|---|
| | Vineyard Theatre (Douglas Aibel: Artistic Director; Jon Nakagawa: Managing Director) (for "Raised in Captivity") [nominee] |
| 1994 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Play |
|---|
| | Vineyard Theatre (Douglas Aibel: Artistic Director; Jon Nakagawa: Managing Director) (for "Pterodactyls") [nominee] |
| 1988 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Revival |
|---|
| | Vineyard Theatre (Douglas Aibel: Artistic Director; Jon Nakagawa: Managing Director) (for "Flora the Red Menace") [nominee] |
| 1986 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Musical |
|---|
| | Vineyard Theatre (Douglas Aibel: Artistic Director; Barbara Zinn Krieger: Executive Director) (for "Goblin Market") [nominee] |