| 2011 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Musical |
|---|
| | The New Group (Scott Elliott: Artistic Director; Geoff Rich: Executive Director) (for "The Kid") [nominee] |
| 2011 Drama Desk Award Special Award |
|---|
 | The New Group (Scott Elliott: Artistic Director; Geoff Rich: Executive Director) (for presenting contemporary new voices, and for uncompromisingly raw and powerful productions) [winner] |
| 2007 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Play |
|---|
| | The New Group (Scott Elliott: Artistic Director; Geoff Rich: Executive Director) (for "The Accomplices") [nominee] |
| 2005 Drama Desk Award Outstanding New Play |
|---|
| | The New Group (Scott Elliott: Artistic Director; Geoff Rich: Executive Director) (for "Sin (A Cardinal Deposed)") [nominee] |
| 2005 Drama Desk Award Outstanding Revival of a Play |
|---|
| | The New Group (Scott Elliott: Artistic Director; Geoff Rich: Executive Director) (for "Hurlyburly") [nominee] |
| 2004 Tony Award® Best Musical |
|---|
| Avenue Q [winner]
Produced by The New Group (Scott Elliott: Artistic Director; Geoff Rich: Executive Director) |
| 2003 Drama Desk Award Outstanding New Musical |
|---|
| | Avenue Q [nominee]
Produced by The New Group (Scott Elliott: Artistic Director; Geoff Rich: Executive Director) |
