| Song List | | | Sung By |
| | | | |
| Act 1 | | | |
| Clackety-Clack | ....................................... | | Washington Irving and Girls |
| | | | |
| It's a Law | ....................................... | | Tienhoven and Council |
| | | | |
| There's Nowhere to Go But Up | ....................................... | | Brom Broeck, Tenpin and Ensemble |
| | | | |
| It Never Was You | ....................................... | | Brom Broeck and Tina Tienhoven |
| | | | |
| How Can You Tell an American? | ....................................... | | Brom Broeck and Washington Irving |
| | | | |
| Will You Remember Me? | ....................................... | | Brom Broeck, Tina Tienhoven and Ensemble |
| | | | |
| One Touch of Alchemy | ....................................... | | Pieter Stuyvesant and Ensemble |
| | | | |
| The One Indispensable Man | ....................................... | | Pieter Stuyvesant and Tienhoven |
| | | | |
| Young People Think About Love | ....................................... | | Tienhoven, Brom Broeck and Ensemble |
| | | | |
| September Song | ....................................... | | Pieter Stuyvesant |
| | | | |
| Act 2 | | | |
| Ballad of the Robbers | ....................................... | | Washington Irving |
| | | | |
| We Are Cut in Twain | ....................................... | | Brom Broeck and Tina Tienhoven |
| | | | |
| There's Nowhere to Go But Up (Reprise) | ....................................... | | Washington Irving |
| | | | |
| To War! | ....................................... | | Pieter Stuyvesant, Council and Male Ensemble |
| | | | |
| Our Ancient Liberties | ....................................... | | Tienhoven, Anthony Corlear and Council |
| | | | |
| Romance and Musketeer | ....................................... | | Ensemble |
| | | | |
| The Scars | ....................................... | | Pieter Stuyvesant and Ensemble |
| | | | |
| Dirge for a Soldier | ....................................... | | Ensemble |
| | | | |
| Ve Vouldn't Gonto Do It | ....................................... | | Ensemble |
| | | | |